web analytics
Best Mattress

Best Extra Firm Mattress

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

Sleeping on a soft, cozy mattress that feels like a cloud is the first thought that comes to our mind when we think of a mattress.

Ideal mattress firmness is one of the top features that come into consideration while buying a mattress.

Firmer feel has many advantages and is recommended for stomach sleepers.

Do you know an extra firm mattress for back pain is considered a boon by many people?

It is the soft mattress that leads to back pain because we tend to ignore the spinal alignment. Switching to a firm mattress is the first advice from the chiropractor if you have consistent back pain.

A side sleeper needs to avoid extra firm mattresses but the stomach and back sleepers prefer a firm mattress. Even a heavy sleeper opt for an extra firm mattress for better sleep and comfort.

Read: Best Mattress Under $1000.

We tested out 13 mattresses with a firmer feel so that you can shortlist the best extra firm mattress. Here is a list of extra firm mattresses you need to consider before buying.

Zinus Support Plus Hybrid Mattress with Euro Top & Extra Firm Feel 

The Zinus Support Plus is one mattress we would recommend if you are looking for the best extra firm mattress. It is highly recommended for heavy people and stomach sleepers.

It is the construction of the mattress that gives an extra firm feel to the mattress. It is made with supportive foam and pocket springs. 

The mattress has only 1.25″ soft foam as a comfort layer followed by 2.5″ high-density foam. The majority of extra-firm feel is provided by 7.5 iCoil pocket springs but has a quilted cover and euro-top for comfort.

The mattress easily supports a heavy person weighing 500lbs. The extra wrapped iCoils eliminates motion transfer usually common with hybrid innerspring mattresses.

To top it up, it comes with a 10-year warranty and a price category of under $500 makes it an exciting prospect.

AMERISLEEP AS1 Memory Foam Extra Firm Mattress

Amerisleep AS1 Memory Foam Mattress - Queen (Firm) - Bed in a Box | Celliant Cover | Bio-Pur Plant Based Material | Cooler Than Memory Foam | USA

  • Goto recommendation for stomach and back sleepers.
  • Bio-Care Foam that recovers quickly.
  • Good for couples.
  • CertiPUR-US certified.

Amerisleep has few models ranging from varying firmness. AS1 is a firm mattress you will need for back pain. The mattress has a proprietary memory foam comfort layer that does not allow the body to be “stuck” in the mattress.

It is a relatively cooler mattress than the other extra firm mattresses listed here. The top comfort layer has an open-cell memory foam layer that dissipates the body.

It uses Bio-Pur, an ultra-breathable material that wicks away heat and keeps your body cool. It is highly responsive and bounces back fast.

The base of the mattress has a thick dense polyfoam that provides extra support and firmness to the bed. It works for most of the sleepers but back sleepers and stomach sleepers will love it for the support provided by the firm mattress surface.

It incorporates HIVE technology and zoned targeted support that helps alleviates back pain.

Sealy Response Performance 11-Inch Firm Tight Top Mattress

Sealy Response Performance 11-Inch Firm Tight Top Mattress, Queen, White

  • Posturepedic Technology for extra support.
  • Premium Extra Firm Mattress with Sealy assurance.
  • Duraflex Coil Edge for better edge support.

Sealy has branded the mattress as “Firm Tight Top” and it is not a marketing gimmick. It lives up the hype and is a firm mattress you will love.

Sealy mattresses are known for quality and high performance that lasts longer. The cheap innerspring mattress can save some money but tend to sag over time.

Recommended by many orthopedics and chiropractors, Sealy uses Posturepedic technology which is useful in providing extra support to heavier areas like the shoulder and lower back.

It uses a Duraflex coil or reinforced coil border on the edges of the mattress for better durability and edge support. 

The comfort foam layer provides conforming support over the encased coils for appropriate pressure relief. It comes with a breathable cover so that you feel fresh throughout the night.

Sealy is an extra firm mattress for a reliable experience and better sleep.

Brooklyn Bedding Titan Hybrid Mattress 

Brooklyn Bedding Titan 11-Inch TitanFlex Hybrid Mattress with TitanCaliber Coils, Queen

  • Heavy-duty coils.
  • Perfect firmness.
  • Made in the U.S.A.
  • CertiPUR-US certified.

Titan by Brooklyn Bedding is one of their highest-selling mattresses. It has a firm feel with good support.

Titan is an 11″ premium mattress with top-notch hybrid-foam mattress construction. It has 1″ of gel memory foam for cooling effect while you sleep.

It has 2″ TitanFlex foam for targeted pressure point relief. The base of the mattress provides the maximum firmness and support. It has 6″ pocketed TitanCaliber coils that form the base of the mattress.

Titan is made in the USA and is CertiPUR-US certified. It also comes with a stress-free 10-year warranty.

In our research, most of the consumers were divided with their views to deem it fit for a firm mattress and extra firm mattress.

Beautyrest Silver BRS900 12 inch Extra Firm Innerspring Mattress

Beautyrest Silver BRS900 12 inch Extra Firm Innerspring Mattress, Queen, Mattress Only

  • Affordable Extra-Firm mattress.
  • 12″ Thick profile.
  • Good edge support.
  • CertiPUR US certified
  • 10-year limited warranty.
  • Made in the USA

With some extraordinary bedding products, Beautyrest has garnered a fanbase in the last couple of years. It has silver and platinum series to cater to a different segment of customers without compromising on the quality.

In the silver series, Beautyrest has an affordable extra-firm mattress for customers looking for queen size mattress under $500. It has an appropriate firmness level to alleviate pressure points.

It has a dual cool cover for people who tend to sleep hot. The top layer is a gel memory foam that regulates body heat and moisture along with the cover. It promotes airflow as well as conforms to your body curves.

The silver 900 series has high quality pocketed coils for firmness and support. Being individually wrapped, they minimize any motion transfer. 

The mattress has more sleeping surface area and stability provided by the edge to edge support. 

Beautyrest delivers on support and comfort. It comes with a 10-year warranty and is CertiPUR-US certified.

Who should Sleep in Firm Mattress?

Ideally one should avoid sleeping on an extra-soft or hard surface. In fact, the best sleeping firmness is medium-firm.

But that’s not a thumb rule.

Sleeping on an extra-firm mattress has its own pros and cons. So who should sleep on a firm mattress and how sleeping position matters?

Stomach Sleepers

When you lie on your stomach the spine loses alignment if you sink into the bed. It is one of the stressful sleeping position for your spine. To keep your spine aligned, you need to sleep on a firm bed. 

The firmness for stomach sleepers varies from individual to individual as body shape and weight may vary.

Back Sleepers

Sleeping on the back puts the least stress on the backbone. There is a tendency of hips to sink in into the soft mattress and spine alignment going for a toss.

A firm mattress holds the body on the top of the mattress and does not allow it to sink.

Heavy People

People who are overweight need a mattress that provides adequate comfort to the back and support. The mattress can sag easily due to the pressure exerted by extra weight.

The heavy people suffer from inadequate support to the neck and shoulders. A good quality firm mattress does not sink and hold the body.

Back Pain

A firm mattress is a top recommendation for someone suffering from back pain.

The underlying reason for lumbar pain is when your lower back is not supported by your existing mattress.

A firm mattress helps support your back and aligns the spine. This helps in reducing the back pain in a matter of a few days.

Side Sleeper

A side sleeper should strictly avoid a firmer mattress. This is the only sleeping position that provides minimal pressure relief and spinal alignment on a firm bed.

Wonder Effects of Firm Bed: Benefits You Need to Know

The word plush is synonymous with soft and luxurious in the bedding industry. This is how the mattresses are marketed by the companies.

Once your body rejects the plush bed, we tend to redefine the meaning of luxury. A luxurious is the one on which you wake fresh and free from any pain.

For many people, the firm mattress provides the luxury of waking up without any lumbar pain.

Here are some of the benefits of sleeping on a firm mattress:

  1. Spine Alignment: One can compromise on anything in a mattress but not a misaligned spine that can lead to a bad back. When you on your back or stomach, a firm mattress keeps your spine aligned.
  2. Sleep Cooler: When you sleep on a firm mattress, the mattress does not cradle, and the body is placed on the top of the mattress rather in the mattress. This allows for better ventilation and disperses heat quickly.
  3. Even Weight Distribution: A firm bed promotes equal distribution of weight and there are no specific areas where pressure point gets created. 

Some Considerations before Picking up your Favourite Firm Mattress 

You know you want a firm mattress!
You understand luxury is when you wake up fresh.

Before you get convinced into buying the best extra-firm mattress. You need to consider a few important points that minimize the chance of any disappointments.


The firmness level can be very subjective and can be used interchangeably by many. Anything ranging from 7 to 10 on the firmness scale of 1 to 10 is firm.

The higher the number, the more firm is the mattress. With the growing demand for extra firm mattresses. Manufacturers are producing models termed as extra firm and firm.

Pick up mattress firmness that works for you and do not follow any advice blindly.

Innerspring/Hybrid Mattress

A large chunk of sales comes from memory foam mattresses. They are the most popular mattress type beating the nearest competitor by a big margin.

Finding an extra firm memory mattress is a challenge. It is important to understand the basic properties of the foam. The firmness level of Memory foam is limited.

The best extra firm mattresses are innerspring or hybrid mattresses. The firmness of the mattress is controlled and designated by the gauge of the coil and supporting high-density foam.

Latex and memory foam are good additions as a comfort layer on the top of the innerspring.

Mattress Sagging

A firmer mattress tends to sag more than any other mattress. This is primarily due to the quality of the material and construction quality.

The people choose to buy a cheap firm mattress and they sag sooner than expected.

As you need a firm mattress for a night of better sleep, it is worth considering a quality mattress. Other factors like body weight and body type play a role in the lifespan of the bed but mattress material has a significant contribution in the long life of the mattress.

Cooler Mattress

Nothing can be more disappointing buying a perfect mattress that gives you sleep without any aches but wakes you up with sweat.

Pick up a mattress with a gel memory foam layer or latex. Both the materials are good at dissipating body heat.

It worth spending more if you can invest in a mattress that uses foam with an open-cell structure. These have a proven record and are known to be cooler mattresses.


We understand when you are looking for an extra firm mattress, you need the right recommendations.

We carefully crafted our list of extra firm mattresses after going through 13 mattresses. We urge you to select the model mentioned above links as the same mattress may be available in a firm as well as extra firm options.


Write A Comment

Pin It