Disclosure – We rely on reader support to run SleepMattressHQ.com. If you purchase products using our links, we may earn a commission. Click here to read about our process.
Before we get into finding the best pillow top mattresses available in 2021. We need to know to answer a few questions about them. Opting for a pillow top mattress has always been a tricky situation for consumers.
Pillow tops are known to have a limited life and tend to sag early though they are comfortable. They are a perfect choice if you are looking for an affordable firm mattress but with a softer feel.
Our Top Recommendations for You
We don’t want our readers to be overwhelmed with too many options to choose from. Our recommendation is based on the research keeping three factors in mind viz. affordability, the material used and aesthetics.
Sealy Euro Pillow Top Mattress
We have carefully crafted the best pillow top mattress list and this is our top pick.
The Sealy mattresses are divided into three types Sealy Essential, Sealy Performance, and Sealy Premium. The essential range is a budget-friendly starting range. But Sealy’s Performance and Premium collection support POSTURPEDIC TECHNOLOGY ™.
It’s innovative POSTURPEDIC TECHNOLOGY ™, offers more support to the body. It targets the heaviest part of your body to deliver reinforced support so that your body stays level while you sleep. You will love the sleep-on-top feeling of the mattress.
It has a three-layer for your comfort. 3 inches SealySupport firm foam, SealyCool cooling gel memory foam and 2 inches SealyCushion air foam. It is an innerspring mattress that uses an encased coil system.
It comes with a ComfortLoft cover which gives you a plush feel. The cover comes with MoistureProtect™. The cover is designed to draw moisture away from your body during the night.
The foams used are CertiPUR-US Certified. The company expects you to give some break-in time so that you adjust fully to your new mattress. The new product smell of the mattress dissipates in a week or two.
Classic Brands Mercer Cool Gel Memory Foam Mattress
As the name suggests, it is a hybrid form with layers of wrapped innerspring and gel memory foam. This gel memory foam gives you a cooling effect at the night, especially for those who have a history of the heating issue of the other mattresses.
The other noticeable highlight of this mattress is the beautiful top knit cover and knit sides which facilitate optimal breathing.
The foams are CertiPUR-US Certified and resistant to bacteria, allergens, and molds. The company offers 100 days of risk-free trial. If you don’t like the mattress for any reason, a full refund will be issued.
Dreamfoam Bedding Doze Pillow Top Mattress
This mattress is quite a value for money looking at the price range and comfort it provides. It has three different thickness levels crafted carefully to give more comfort and support. It has a zoned foam built-up which provides extra support to the body.
The mattress foam is CertiPUR-US certified. The certification and 10-year warranty ensure extra peace of mind.
Signature Sleep Hybrid Coil Mattress
Signature Sleep as a company has been in this business for the last 50 years. So they have vast experience and confidence in their products. They are known for making durable mattresses.
This mattress stands apart from other mattresses for its body to breathe quality. The mattress contains rayon derived from bamboo which absorbs moisture and dries quickly.
The fabric of the cover is quite durable with similar properties. It gives you a dry feel and is excellent in absorbing moisture.
Mattress uses encased coils which helps in equal distribution of weight which reduces motion transfer. It contours effectively with the curves of the body shape.
The mattress foam is low VOC and CertiPUR-US Certified with flame retardant properties.
Zinus Sleep Master Ultima Comfort Euro Top Mattress
This mattress was launched somewhere at the end of 2011. It is one of the highest sellers from Zinus. The mattress uses iCoil pocketed springs, foam, and fiber quilted euro box top cover. The iCoil technology used in the mattress guarantees almost no motion transfer. Thereby ensuring less disruptive sleep for your partner.
Ultima comfort uses CertiPUR-US certified high-quality foam for better performance over a period of time.
Why Pillow Top Mattress is for you?
Are you looking for an affordable mattress?
Are you looking for a budget mattress?
If yes, probably pillow top mattress is the best bet for you. It doesn’t break your bank and is more affordable without much compromising on comfort. In our research, we came across so many individuals who are looking for a firm mattress with a softer feel. Opt for a firm mattress.
Is this the most comfortable mattress?
No, there are better options available but you need to spend much higher. Looking at the price range of pillow-top mattresses, they are the best option for the kind of comfort you are getting for your dollars.
Comfort: Pillowtop padding is generally comprised of normal foam, memory foam, latex, cotton, etc. The variation in pricing is not about brands but also the kind of padding used. You should opt for relevant padding, looking at the kind of softer feel you need.
Reduces Pain: A lot of people suffer from pain and stiffness after their sleep. It provides good contour support to your shoulder and back. It will help in providing support to your back. For side sleepers, it will keep your shoulders relaxed. Make sure you choose the right padding for you.
Better Stability: It is time for some better sleep if you are upgrading from your usual innerspring or coil mattress. In your old innerspring bed, you might be used to motion transfer and feeling of movement when your partner moves or changes side in bed. Choosing a comfortable soft pillow top mattress will reduce that to a greater extent.
Reasons to Avoid: It is one of the cheapest options in the mattress category. Let us try to list down some reasons why people avoid buying so that you can make an informed decision if you plan to buy one.
Sagging: These mattresses are prone to sagging or indentations. Over a period of time with usage, they tend to take up body shape and indentations become deep. This kind of sagging may cause discomfort on regular use. Although many manufacturers cover the sagging issue in the warranty. But you might face issues while claiming the same if the user does not meet the terms and conditions.
A good decision would be to choose high-quality memory foam or latex in the padding layers. This will more or less take care of this issue.
Heat Retention Issue: This can be a deal-breaker depending upon your body type and which part of the country you are in. The memory foam used has an inherent property of retaining the heat. It can cause quite discomfort especially if you sweat a lot. We highly recommend latex or gel memory foam padding which will reduce this to some extent.
Important Tips to Consider Before Buying
Let us highlight key points to consider when you are selecting your ideal pillow top mattress.
Padding: As they have multi-layered padding so choose a quality layer made up of memory foam, gel foam, viscose foam, latex, etc. Avoid polyester as they have a very limited life and they get hard in a few years. The quality of the padding layers will decide the overall comfort and longevity of the mattress.
Warranty & Certification: Opt for a mattress with a good and longer warranty. The longer warranty ensures the quality and faith of the manufacturer in his product. In case of some issues in your mattress, you are secured for a longer period of time. Invest in a CertiPUR-US certified mattress. The certification ensures that the mattress does not use anything which could be harmful to your health. A certified mattress is a peace of mind.
Back Support: The material used in your mattress has a direct relation to the kind of lumbar support it can provide. Understand the kind of back support you need as you will be using it daily for at least 7 to 8 hours. You need to wake up fresh and free from any strains in the back.
Memory foam is known to sag after a few years but it takes up the body shape easily. It has a tendency to retain the heat. So make sure the memory foam used is of high quality.
Latex provides better support as compared to the memory foam. The support it provides to pressure point is also rated better than memory foam. Heat retention is minimal in latex.
Polyester is the cheapest option but our recommendation is clear. Avoid!
Aesthetics: This is going to be in your bedroom so it should ooze luxury. This is the reason many customers end up buying Euro Top Mattresses and ready to shell out a little extra. Check out the quality and patterns of the fabric used. Any cheap fabric or mismatched color tone can spoil the look of a mattress. Quality of stitching also adds to the overall aesthetics.
Carefully selecting the firm mattress is the key to your spine health. Ensure the firmness of the mattress depending upon your favorite sleeping position.
If you are sleeping mostly on the stomach, make sure you choose a more medium-firm mattress. Choosing a very soft mattress, the spine will curve away from the natural position. It can lead to stiffness and related pain in the back.
Side sleepers should opt for a softer mattress so that mattress can take up the shape of the body and shoulders. It will help the spine to be in its natural shape while you are sleeping.
Pillow top mattress is not associated with mattresses that provide the best quality sleep. People tend to spend thousands of dollars to get the right kind of mattress that will give them the best sleep quality.
However, they provide a good sleep initially but the performance tends to come down over a period of time. It is due to the factors which go against this mattress as discussed above.
Some Frequently Asked Questions By Consumers
- What is a Pillow Top Mattress?
A pillow top mattress is a firm mattress with a layered padding stitched to it. This layered padding on top provides a soft to very a soft feel. The firm mattress below the padding is an innerspring or coil mattress. This extra padding looks like a pillow on the top of mattress hence the name “pillow top” mattress.
- What is a Euro Top Mattress?
To put it simply, the euro top mattress is a step-up version of the pillow top mattress. Euro top mattress also has padding but it gives the mattress a single unit feel. The padding is visible above the mattress. So euro tops score better when it comes to aesthetics.
- Is Pillow Top Mattress recommended for side sleepers?
No, ideally they are related to any particular sleeping style. These are affordable mattresses tuned to make them budget-friendly. But if you opt for a mid-segment or above range, a side sleeper should feel comfortable. Make sure the pillow top used has memory foam with good thickness so that it can adapt to your body form.
- What is the difference between Euro Top & Pillow Top Mattresses?
Euro top mattresses are a better version of pillow-top mattresses. Internally the structure is very similar but the euro top is aesthetically different and better. The only difference between the two is the padding style. Euro top mattress padding is part of the mattress and visually gives a look of a single mattress.
- Do Pillow Top Mattresses sag?
Relatively speaking, yes they do sag with time. But remember we pay quite less than the other type of mattresses. So the life span is relatively less than other high-end mattresses. The cheaper the mattress, the more the chances of sagging. A good pillow top mattress should be good for 5-7 years without losing shape.
- Should we use a topper for pillow top mattress?
No, you should not as the mattress is already having a topper. If your mattress is a few years old now and you are not happy. We will suggest you should replace it with a new one.
- How long Pillow Top Mattresses last?
A good pillow top mattress lasts around 5 to 7 years and should have a certified foam. As per our research, the certified mattress generally provides a stress-free experience. Lastly, you are expected to flip and rotate your mattress at least once in 3 months.
Pillow top mattresses are already the cheapest hybrid mattress option if you are looking purely into the affordable budget range. They can cost you less than $1000 and up to $1400 in some cases.
If you don’t want to spend on a new mattress right now. Don’t look further go for the mattress topper to give a new life to your existing mattress setup.